From Wall Street to First Editions: The Story Behind One of NJ’s Last Old Book Shops

Step inside the world of timeless stories and collectible treasures as The Jersey Buzz Podcast sits down with the owner of The Old Book Shop of Bordentown, one of New Jersey’s last standing used bookstores. This isn’t just a business—it’s a passion project turned community gem, preserving history one dusty jacket at a time.

A BUSINESS ROOTED IN PASSION

From a career in stockbroking and boardroom deals to being surrounded by paperbacks and literary gems, our guest didn’t just pivot—he followed a lifelong love for books that began in childhood. His first love? A library copy of The Complete Works of Sherlock Holmes—a book he still owns today.

WHY BOOKS STILL MATTER

In an age of screens, Kindles, and Audible subscriptions, The Old Book Shop reminds us that holding a book is a sensory experience:

• The smell of aged pages

• The feel of a dusty cover

• The thrill of discovery

Despite the digital shift, the shop still thrives thanks to its 8% online presence and strong local support. “People come in not for what they know they want—but to find something they didn’t know they needed.”

BUILDING BOOKWORMS FROM THE GROUND UP

With a huge collection of children’s books—from classic board books to (Young Adult) YA favorites—the shop ensures the next generation develops a love for reading. Teachers and parents alike visit regularly to buy stacks of affordable reads—much cheaper than the big box retailers.

“Books are not just intellectual experiences—they’re emotional experiences.”

 A COLLECTOR’S PARADISE

From a first edition of Dracula (yes, really!) to a signed Babe Ruth book, this shop is a haven for collectors. Wondering how to start collecting? The advice is simple:
👉 Collect what you love.
👉 Focus on condition.
👉 Learn how to identify first editions (tip: check the copyright page and dust jacket!).

FUN FACT: DUST JACKETS MATTER!

Modern first editions can skyrocket in value because of their dust jackets—sometimes worth thousands on their own. So, next time you’re tempted to toss one out...don’t!

MORE THAN A BOOKSTORE – A TOWN TREASURE

Located in the heart of the walkable, historic Downtown Bordentown, The Old Book Shop is more than a place to shop—it’s a destination. Grab a book, sip a coffee, sit outside, and enjoy the charm of a town that values its stories.

SUPPORT LOCAL. SUPPORT LEGACY.

Before clicking “Buy Now” on a big box site, consider stopping by a local bookstore. These spaces offer something Amazon never will—a conversation, a smile, and a real connection to history and community.

Take Away from Podcast Host April Sette

“Books feed the soul—and supporting local businesses fuels the heart of our towns. We're proud to spotlight places that make our communities lovable, livable, and worth buzzing about.”

🔗 Connect with Doug – Old Book Shop of Bordentown

Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/oldbookshopbordentown

Website - https://www.oldbookshopofbordentown.com/

Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/old_book_shop_of_bordentown/

The Jersey Buzz Podcast is your local voice for transformative stories and authentic conversations that inspire.

Real People. Real Stories. Real Treasures.

📢 SUPPORT THE MOVEMENT - Help us grow our Hyper Local Channel!
If you believe in the power of positive media, please Subscribe, Like, and Comment—your engagement helps amplify voices that matter. Let’s start local and spread a ripple of real change.